Our 10 Best Mascara For Redheads In 2024

Updated on January 7, 2024

Did you know that most brands that manufacture black or black/ brown mascara shades do not work for redheads? Redheads have unique special hair combined with a special complexion, skin, pale eyelashes, and a fiery personality. Applying black or brown mascara on pale eyelashes appears too harsh and does not suit a redhead’s natural complexion well. That is why redheads need to use mascara that is designed to suit their pale lashes and complexion to enjoy a more natural, defined look. If you are a proud redhead, here is a list of the best mascara for redheads that you should try.

Editor’s Choices

10 Best Mascara For Redheads Of 2024

1. Just For Redheads Mascara Studio (Best Smudge Proof)

This is one of the best mascaras for redheads in the market. The formula is long-wearing and will not wear off, flake, or fade throughout the day. It is enriched with vitamin E and panthenol to promote healthy and strong lashes. The product is friendly for people with sensitive skin and brings out your natural beauty without looking exaggerated. This mascara comes with a dual-ended lash comb and brush that enables you to enhance the volume of your lashes and transform their look like never before. This mascara darkens and adds warmth to your pale lashes, giving them a more defined look. The formula is easily buildable to create your desired look and is smudge-proof and water-resistant.

Benefits

• High-tech mascara
• Sensitive skin friendly
• Achieve your dream lashes every day!
• Smudge-proof
• Washable
• Will not flake or fade

Negatives

• Runny consistency

2. blinc Amplified Tubing Mascara (Best Fade Proof)

This mascara is designed for you if you are a redhead with sensitive skin and eyes. It is clinically tested to be non-irritating making it suitable for people with sensitive skin. This mascara is easily buildable and long-wearing. It does not smudge, run, smear, or fade even if you rub your eyes or cry. The liquid formula forms tiny water-resistant tubes around your lashes for maximum amplification and hold. The tubes bind to your lashes, making it smudge-proof and preventing it from running off. This mascara helps you to amplify the lash volume and length for an everyday glam look.

Benefits

• Buildable mascara
• Smudge-proof
• Great for sensitive eyes and sensitive skin
• Easy to use and apply
• Feel confident
• Manufactured in USA

Negatives

• Expensive

3. COVERGIRL Lash Blast Volume Mascara (Best Cruetly Free)

If you want to instantly create a mega volume of your lashes, go for COVERGIRL Lash Blast Volume Mascara. It gives you instant volume and blast of fullness and length. This formula is designed to max out every lash and can create ten times more volume instantly. This volumizing mascara for redheads coats each lash evenly without clamping or flaking. It is available in 4 different shades, allowing you to choose how bold you want to look. The formula is hypoallergenic and is suitable for contact lens wearers. The mascara is smudge and smear-proof and lasts all day long.

Benefits

• Ultimate big-lash look
• Instant blast of fullness and length
• Available in four different colors
• Coats each lash with no clumping or flaking
• Cruelty-Free
• Smudge and smear-proof

Negatives

• May clump

4. L’Oreal Paris Makeup Voluminous Mascara (Best For Deep Burgundy)

Get long and full eyelashes of your choice by using the L’Oreal Paris Makeup Voluminous Mascara. This product is uniquely designed to resist clamping and soften and builds your lashes up to 5x their natural thickness. It is packed with a volume maximizing brush that thickens your lashes evenly and smoothly, giving them a wow look. This mascara is made with an air-whipped formula that makes it as light as air volume and is easily buildable to create the volume you want. The mascara is waterproof and ideal for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. This formula offers all-day wear by resisting flaking and clamping and leaves your lashes supple, soft, and full.

Benefits

• Build lashes up to 5X their natural thickness
• Suitable for sensitive eyes
• Innovative volumizing formulas
• Create you perfect eye makeup
• Lightweight
• Volume bristle

Negatives

• Expensive

5. Benefit They’re Real! Beyond Mascara (Best For Lengthening)

If you aim to have lashes beyond your belief, go for the Benefit They’re Real! Beyond Mascara. This lengthening mascara adds volume, and separates lifts, and curls your lashes quickly to give you the bold look you desire. It comes with a perfect specially designed brush that is wide enough to comb through your lashes. The brush has a rounded tip to tease out tiny lashes vertically and then brush through to get the maximum length. The brush features staggered bristles that grab the lashes close to the root to boost the length and volume beyond belief. Proper use of this brush helps you reveal lashes you never knew you had. This long-wearing formula does not smudge, clamp, or dry out. It is easy to apply and stays put all day.

Benefits

• Long-lasting
• Waterproof
• Easy to use
• Suitable for sensitive eyes
• Longwear

Negatives

• It may not be waterproof

6. Too Faced Twice The Sex Mascara Duo Set (Best For Thickening)

If you want a dramatic blast on your lashes, use this mascara for long and full lashes. The formula is gentle and all-natural, making it ideal for people with sensitive eyes and skin. It is infused with moisturizing ingredients like acacia Senegal tree extract, peptides, and a film-forming polymer that conditions your lashes while giving them a fuller and thicker appearance.

Its unique applicator allows you to get all your lashes without clamping to ac have thick and long lashes. The formula is extremely buildable, and you can layer it up to achieve the desired volume. It is long-wearing and will look fresh all day.

Benefits

• Extreme-volume mascara
• Double your mascara’s longevity
• Achieves high volume and thickens
• Full size & travel size available
• Waterproof

Negatives

• Expensive

7. Essence cosmetics Lash Princess False Mascara (Best Fragrance Free)

Essence cosmetics Lash Princess False Mascara will help you create dramatic volume on your lashes. It is packed with a conic shape fiber brush that offers dramatic volume and sculpted length without globs or clamps. This oil-free mascar5a does not fade, flake, or wear. It is ideal for an all-day long-lasting mascara. It allows you to go about all your day without flaking, fading, or doing any touchups. If you want instant defined volume, apply one coat of this mascara to your lashes. If you want to look bold and extra voluminous, apply 2-3 coats, and you will be impressed. This formula defines and separates lashes while giving you a bold look. With this product, no falsies are needed.

Benefits

• Built-in brush
• Long-wearing
• Long-lasting
• Non-clumping
• Non-flaking
• Fragrance-free, Oil free, Animal byproduct-free, Alcohol-free, Paraben free

Negatives

• Takes longer to dry

8. Maybelline New York Sky High Washable Mascara (Best For Multiplying)

You can achieve limitless length and the full volume of your lashes by using the Maybelline New York Sky High Washable Mascara. This formula is infused with bamboo extract and fibers to help you achieve full, long, and lightweight lashes that do not flake or smudge. The package comes with mascara and a liquid liner that offers a smooth glide with no skips or slips and is waterproof. The mascara has an exclusive flex tower brush that bends your lashes to volumize and extend them from root to tip for maximum length and volume. This product is ophthalmologist and allergy tested and is suitable for people with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

Benefits

• Washable mascara
• Lightweight
• Suitable for sensitive eyes
• Waterproof
• Removes easily

Negatives

• It may flake

9. Mineral Fusion Lash Lengthening Mascara (Best Natural Cosmetics)

For achieving the maximum length of your lashes with minimal effort, go for the Mineral Fusion Lash Lengthening mascara. This is a hypoallergenic and botanical-infused lash-lengthening formula. It coats all your lashes without flaking, caking, or clamping for maximum length and volume. The formula is made with minerals that apply smoothly to darken and define your lashes. The infused botanicals nourish and condition your lashes to promote their health and vitality. The formula is easily buildable, and you can layer it on as much as possible for a more dramatic look. This lengthening g mascara is fragrance-free and is made with no harsh ingredients making it ideal for people with sensitive eyes and skin.

Benefits

• Coats each and every lash without flaking
• Nourish your skin
• Gluten, parabens free
• Waterproof
• Volumizing
• Lengthening
• Lash Curling

Negatives

• It may not be easy to remove

10. bareMineralsEscentualsLashtopia Mascara (Best For Moisturizing)

This liquid mascara is formulated with nourishing and conditioning minerals for your lashes’ health and vitality. It also has moisturizing ingredients like glycerin and castor seed oil that keep your lashes soft all through. This mascara provides an abundance of lash volume while lifting and separating the lashes to create a fanned-out fullness. This formula lasts all day and is smudge, flake, and clump-resistant. The formula is air whipped and feels weightless on your lashes. It is very easy to remove and suitable for contact lens wearers.

Benefits

• The all-day formula
• Clump- and flake-resistant
• Keep lashes soft
• Cruelty-free
• Easy to use

Negatives

• It may not be waterproof

Conclusion

If you are a redhead who feels like black mascara makes your pale eyelashes look too conspicuous, you may be using the wrong mascara. With your special complexion, skin, and head, you need a mascara that is compatible with your looks. That is why we have compiled a list of the best mascaras for redheads to help you choose one that will amplify your looks. When choosing the best mascara for redheads, it’s good to consider features like waterproof, volume, length, shade, and brush. Try out one of these and let us know your feedback.