Top 10 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencils In 2024

Updated on February 8, 2024

Do you wish to have bold, well-sculpted brows with a perfect arch? Grooming your eyebrows is not all about trimming and tweezing. It entails filling in the sparse areas, curating a perfect arch, and making them bold. The good thing is that you don’t have to go to the salon for microblading, lamination or blow tinting or use expensive high-end brow products to define and fill your brows. Using the best drugstore eyebrow pencils is an easy and affordable way to sculpt and fill your brows for a perfect-looking brow. 

With a good brow pencil, you can transform your brows effortlessly to get the precise brow look you desire. Here is a list of the best drugstore eyebrow pencils that will do magic to your brows without you spending too much penny.

Editor’s Choices

Top 10 Drugstore Eyebrow Pencils

1. Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil (Best Waterproof)

If you have light and sparse eyebrows, Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil should be the pencil to use. It helps to create a softly defined natural-looking brow with its teardrop-shaped applicator.

All you have to do is to shape your brows with the pencil and blend with the eyebrow spoolie brush to get your desired brow look. This long-lasting eyebrow pencil is available in four shades which include: blonde, soft brown, deep brown and medium brown.

Key Features:

• Non-greasy formula
• Longwearing
• Available in four different shades
• Sweat-resistant
• Tear-drop shaped applicator for easy usage

2. Goof Proof Brow Pencil Eyebrow Shaping and Filling (Best Overall)

This is an ultra-easy filling and shaping eyebrow pencil. It features a non-sharpen goof-proof custom tapered tip that glides on for easy and fast brow filling and defining. It provides a soft color that creates naturally full, beautiful brows.

The eye pencil comes with a built-in blending spoolie-brush that helps to complete the shape of your brows easily. It is available in 12 stunning shades that fill and shape your brows flawlessly and offers a wide selection to choose from to match your style, mood, and skin tone.

Key Features:

• Available in 12 different shades
• Water-proof
• Long-wearing
• Glides on easily

3. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow Pencil (Best Cruelty Free)

This is an ultra-skinny micro pencil that coats and fills even the finest hair with color for a natural-looking finish. It shapes, defines, and fills sparse and over-tweezed brows to give bold and well-sculpted beautiful eyebrows. The tip is super skinny that helps you draw fine lines to create natural brow hairs.

The best thing about NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow Pencil is that it comes with hard-to-find colors that can be blended to create a custom hue. Use the lighter shade to fill in your hair and the darker shade to define your brow’s shape.

Key Features:

• Available in 8 different hard-to-find colors
• Easy to apply 
• Long-lasting
• Vegan formula

4. L’Oreal Makeup Brow Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil (Best Ultra-Fine)

For brows that are flawless and naturally-looking, use L’Oreal Makeup Brow Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil. It comes with an ultra-fine self-sharpening brow pencil that fills in sparse areas and gaps and has a spoolie brush style to comb and brush hairs in place to define brow shape.

The formula is water-proof and suitable for people with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. It is available in seven shades, including a variation on blonde and brunette plus a soft black.

Key Features:

• Water-proof
• Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
• Available in 7 shades
• Ultra-fine point tip for easy application

5. Rimmel London Professional Eyebrow Pencil (Best For Fill Gaps)

This is a professional eyebrow pencil that can be used to enhance and refine your eyebrows’ shape. You can use it to fill gaps and lengthen your brow’s arch to create the desired look. It comes with a brush head that helps to brush hairs and keep them in place for a more defined brow look and blending purposes.

Get yourself fuller eyebrows that look all-natural with this unique eyebrow pencil. It comes in three different shades of dark brown, black, brown and hazel.

Key Features:

• Available in 3 shades
• Smudge-resistant
• Long-wearing
• Easy to use

6. CoverGirl Easy Breezy Brow Micro-Fine + Define (Best For Sensitive Skin)

Are you looking for an ideal eyebrow pencil that requires no sharpening? CoverGirl Easy Breezy Brow Micro-Fine + Define got you covered. It is a softly pigmented pencil that is available in five shades and provides a natural look.

The pencil has a built-in spoolie with a micro-fine tip that allows you to easily fill and define your brows. The best thing is that this pencil can be used as a soft liner for your eyes and can be removed easily with soap and water.

Key Features:

• Suitable for sensitive eyes
• No sharpening is required
• Removes easily with soap and water
• Built-in spoolie with a super-fine tip

7. Chella Eyebrow Pencil, Beautiful Blonde – Vegan (Best Long Wearing)

This is a good drugstore eyebrow pencil with beautiful blonde shades that fits everyone with blonde hair to light brown hair. The pencil has a smooth consistency that glides into place easily and can be lightly blended to give a truly natural-looking finish.

This long-wearing pencil is available in nine beautiful shades. The pencil gives precise strokes without the need for a sharpener. The built-in spoolie helps you to blend your makeup easily for a more natural look.

Key Features:

• Available in 9 beautiful shades
• Long-wearing
• Smooth consistency
• Blendable

8. Glo Skin Beauty Precision Brow Pencil in Blonde (Best Mineral Base)

This is a precision natural-looking brow enhancement pencil. It comes in a mineral-based formula that fills in brows in scarce areas and where there are gaps. It helps to softly sculpt and shape your brows to create a more natural look.

This powder-based formula is good for all climates and will even last during warm weather. It comes with a two-in-one sculpting brush for shaping and blending. The pencil is available in three shades and requires sharpening to create precise lines.

Key Features:

• Available in three shades
• Defines and fills eyebrows
• Long-wearing even during warm weather
• Does not flake

9. JORDANA Fabubrow Eyebrow Pencil-Medium Brown (Best Long Lasting)

This is a long-lasting formula that fills in, defines, and colors eyebrows. It comes with a built-in comb that helps you to brush your untamed hairs so that you can define and shape them in a natural brow-looking way.

The pencil sharpens into a fine point that allows you to draw precise lines to create a well-sculpted brow. It comes in a shade of medium brown that is suitable for most people.

Key Features:

• Long-lasting
• Easy to use
• Glides easily
• Water-resistant

10. Honest Beauty Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie (Best Natural-Ingredients)

This is a beauty eyebrow pencil that creates a soft natural-looking brow. The pencil is easily buildable and blendable and has a soft tip that glides on for easy application. The pencil formula is enriched with jojoba seed oil that helps to reshape and condition your brow.

Key Features:

• Dermatologist-tested
• Enriched with jojoba seed oil
• Buildable coverage
• Easy application

How To Choose The Right Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil?

Shade Range

The shade range of any beauty product is very important to consider before settling on a product. Look for a drugstore eyebrow pencil that offers a shade that matches your skin tone.

When choosing eyebrow pencils, you need a shade that is lighter than your natural eyebrow color. This will keep the look blended and tame against your natural hair. You will fill in the gaps without creating darkened spots.

Darker shades apply to brow gels, so when using the eyebrow pencil, don’t make the mistake of choosing a darker shade. That is why you need an eyebrow pencil with different shades so that you can pick a shade lighter than your natural brow color.

Ease of application

The last thing you want is to buy an eyebrow pencil that is hard to apply. Look for a brow pencil that has features that allow easy application. The good thing is that most beauty stores allow you to test a product on your skin before buying it. Look for features like a brush and how the tip is designed. Also, consider the blendability of the eyebrow pencil formula.

Ingredients

Look for a drugstore eyebrow pencil that is formulated with skin-friendly ingredients. This will prevent you from using products that can trigger allergies once you apply them to your face. Checking the ingredients will help you avoid buying a pencil that can irritate and have redness areas around your eyes. Choose an eyebrow pencil that is compatible with your skin.

Multi-functionality

An eyebrow pencil that performs different functions is always the best. Choose an eye pencil that will help you shape and define your eyebrows at a go.

Frequently Asked Questions

Conclusion

Grooming eyebrows have become like a must-do thing for any modern woman. With many beauty products designed to groom your eyebrows, a pencil is one of the must-haves. Finding the right eyebrow pencil can be difficult from the variety of options available in the market.

This list will help you select some of the best drugstore eyebrow pencils. Our favorite pencil is the Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil. It helps to create a softly defined natural-looking brow with its teardrop-shaped applicator.

This long-lasting eyebrow pencil is available in four shades: blonde, soft brown, deep brown, and medium brown. The pencil formula is non-greasy and sweat-resistant, which makes it last the whole day.

Recommended Articles

• Best Drugstore Face Washes and Cleansers: Every Skin Type And Concern
• Best Wrinkle Fillers That Will Actually Work
• Best Hair Color To Cover Gray Hair: According to Experts